Skip to content

Criticism

A platform for insightful analysis and passionate discourse on cinema and television.

Our criticism section offers reviews, essays, and interviews that deepen engagement with the films and series featured. It champions thoughtful, cinephile-driven critique.

By fostering dialogue between critics and audiences, it enriches the understanding of cinematic art in its many forms.

Summer H. Howell as Carrie White in the Amazon series adaptation

Criticism

Mike Flanagan's 'Carrie' Series Flattens Horror in a Too-Tame Teen Drama

Catriona Vale · October 1, 2026

A fresh take on Stephen King's horror classic struggles under the weight of its own gentleness, turning what could be a fiery adaptation into a subdued teen drama.

'You Can See Everything' Review: Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's Elizabeth Holmes Documentary Is Boundary-Pushing and Absurd story still

Criticism

‘You Can See Everything’ Examines Elizabeth Holmes’s Last Days with Boundary-Pushing Absurdity

Catriona Vale · September 7, 2026

Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s documentary blurs the lines between investigation and performance, exposing the murky reality behind Elizabeth Holmes’s final months before prison.

Cristian Mungiu’s ‘Fjord’ cast at the film’s premiere, showing Sebastian Stan and Renate Reinsve in character, amid a Norwegian landscape.

Criticism

‘Fjord’ Review: Cristian Mungiu Explores Cultural Clash and Religious Tensions in Norway

Catriona Vale · May 18, 2026

Sebastian Stan and Renate Reinsve star in Cristian Mungiu’s latest film, a tense drama examining religious conservatism and liberal intolerance amid Norway’s idyllic landscape.

Oscars Review: Conan O'Brien Does It Again — This Time, for the Cinephiles story still

Criticism

Oscars 2026: Conan O’Brien’s Second Host Run Delivers Cinephile Charm and Genuine Gratitude

Catriona Vale · March 16, 2026

The 98th Academy Awards proved that a host who loves movies and isn’t afraid to be himself can elevate the ceremony beyond rote spectacle, with Conan O’Brien once again striking the perfect balance of humor and heartfelt sincerity.

At the 2026 Olympics Opening Ceremony, Weirdness Was in Short Supply — but Not Attempts at 'Harmony' story still

Criticism

Milan-Cortina 2026 Olympics Opening: A Quiet Show of 'Harmony' Amid Sparse Energy

Catriona Vale · February 6, 2026

The 2026 Winter Olympics opening in Milan and Cortina aimed for harmony but delivered a more subdued spectacle, with an emphasis on tradition over eccentricity.

'Whalefall' Review: Austin Abrams Battles a Bellyful of Daddy Issues in Brutal Survival Thriller story still

Criticism

‘Whalefall’ review: Austin Abrams grapples with daddy issues inside a killer whale’s belly

Catriona Vale · April 21, 2024

A brutal underwater survival thriller that dives into trauma as much as it does into visceral body horror, ‘Whalefall’ balances emotional baggage with jaw-dropping effects.

'VisionQuest' Review: Marvel's Tedious Bad-Dad Drama Series Ends a Shortsighted Era of MCU TV story still

Criticism

‘VisionQuest’ Wraps Up Marvel’s Shortsighted MCU TV Era with a Tedious Self-Discovery Saga

Catriona Vale · April 19, 2024

Marvel’s latest series, ‘VisionQuest,’ signals the end of an era for MCU television, delivering a drawn-out, monotonous meditation on identity that leaves little to the imagination or excitement.

‘The Lowdown’ Season 2 Review: Ethan Hawke and Betty Gilpin Light Up a Rollicking, Moving Mystery story still

Criticism

‘The Lowdown’ Season 2: Ethan Hawke and Betty Gilpin Shine in a Gritty, Charismatic Mystery

Catriona Vale · April 15, 2024

Sterlin Harjo’s second season deepens its noir roots, with Hawke and Gilpin delivering compelling performances that elevate the series’ dark, layered storytelling.

'Sense and Sensibility' Review: Daisy Edgar-Jones and George MacKay Suffuse an Unfussy Jane Austen Adaptation with Earthly Sensuality story still

Criticism

‘Sense and Sensibility’ (2026) Review: Daisy Edgar-Jones and George MacKay Bring Earthy Sensuality to a Faithful Austen Revival

Catriona Vale · April 7, 2024

Georgia Oakley's latest adaptation of Jane Austen's classic is a meticulous, understated take that emphasizes naturalism and sensuality over flashy modernization.

'Crystal Lake' Review: Over-the-Top Kills Succumb to an Underbaked Story in A24's 'Friday the 13th' Prequel story still

Criticism

‘Crystal Lake’ Fails to Elevate Its Gore-Laden Prequel Despite Flashy Kills

Catriona Vale · February 23, 2024

A24’s ‘Friday the 13th’ prequel stumbles over its undercooked story, leaving viewers with over-the-top kills and little else to savor.

The Future of Cinema Is the Cinema Itself story still

Criticism

Reviving Community Cinema: How the Rockaway Film Festival Is Reimagining the Future of Film Culture

Catriona Vale · February 11, 2024

In a landscape where traditional cinemas shutter and remote locations become ‘cinema deserts,’ the Rockaway Film Festival exemplifies a grassroots effort to keep the cinematic experience alive and local.

'Animals' Review: Ben Affleck's Tedious New Netflix Thriller Is Quite Literally Just Bad TV story still

Criticism

Ben Affleck’s ‘Animals’ Flops with Tedious Plot and Lack of Style on Netflix

Catriona Vale · January 16, 2024

Aiming for political intrigue, ‘Animals’ stalls in blandness, revealing itself as forgettable TV rather than a compelling feature.